Decision Library
The decision is yours. Find the resources to work it through.
Explore worked examples, practical tools, and professional learning for the GMP decisions you need to explain.
When the FDA inspector asks who authorized this and why, ComplianceWorxs is the record that answers.
Try “CAPA effectiveness,” “batch release” or “OOS investigation.”
How these resources work
- Evidence What was reviewed, and what it showed.
- Judgment How it was weighed, and what else was considered.
- Risk The uncertainty that remains, and what bounds it.
Each Case File is a complete worked example built on a fictional case. It shows the reasoning in full so you can recognize what your own record is missing.
Choose your decision
Start with a free worked example
See what a complete decision record looks like.
Explore the Batch Release Authorization Case File before choosing resources for your own decision.
Investigations and CAPA
Batch release and disposition
Change, validation and documents
Investigations and CAPA
CAPA effectiveness
The corrective actions are complete. Two reviewers read the same effectiveness evidence and reach different conclusions.
The inspector asks “Who made the determination that this CAPA was effective, and what evidence supported that conclusion?”
Start here
CAPA Effectiveness Case File
Close a coating-defect CAPA as effective after six lots, with follow-up.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- Six lots at 0.02% to 0.04% defects against a 0.10% criterion set before the data, and the other products on the same pan checked.
- Judgment
- Completed actions were not the basis for closure; extending monitoring before closing was considered and rejected.
- Risk
- Two durability questions carried forward with owners and dates; any lot above 0.10% in the next two quarters reopens the CAPA.
- The Director, Quality Assurance, under Quality Unit CAPA closure authority, not delegated.
- CAPA Effectiveness Case File Case File $149
- CAPA Sufficiency Review Decision tool $39
- CAPA Decision Experience Decision Experience Free
- Who Authorized This CAPA Closure? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Complaint Investigation Closure? Inspection question
- CAPA effectiveness documentation Guide
- Beyond Documentation: Using Intelligent Systems to Examine GMP Decisions Article
- The Business of Compliance: What Quality Leaders Are Really Asking the Business to Fund Article
- New evidence has arrived. Does the earlier decision still stand, or does it need to be made again? Article
- How Do We Know It Worked? Podcast
- CAPA Effectiveness: Two Warning Letters, One Failure Podcast
Coming soon
- The Record in Practice, Unit 3: Completing an action does not establish effectiveness. Practice unit Releases December 14
- A CAPA Is Closed. What Proves It Worked? Webinar Coming soon
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual CAPA effectiveness decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Investigations and CAPA
Deviation closure
The deviation is being closed on an operator-error cause, and nobody has shown that the other causes were ruled out.
The inspector asks “Who made the disposition decision for this deviation, and what evidence did they review?”
Start here
Deviation Closure Case File
Close the deviation; operator technique confirmed as the cause.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- Equipment and systemic causes ruled out through maintenance records, environmental monitoring, and deviation history.
- Judgment
- Closed with retraining; holding the deviation open for a broader investigation was rejected.
- Risk
- Whether the technique holds beyond three supervised fills; a second technique deviation reopens it.
- The Senior QA Manager, under Quality Unit closure authority, not delegated.
- Deviation Closure Case File Case File $149
- Deviation Decision Check Decision tool $39
- Unit 1: Was the work performed? Practice unit 25 min
- Unit 1: What would establish performance? Practice unit 25 min
- Who Authorized the Deviation Disposition? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Root Cause Determination? Inspection question
- Deviation root cause documentation Guide
- Deviation investigation before closure Guide
- The second person’s check line is blank. What establishes that the check happened? Article
- A record entry is missing. Was the work not written down, or not done? Article
- Who authorized the deviation closure, and what was set aside? Article
- The Deviation Was Closed. The Problem Wasn't. Podcast
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual deviation closure decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Investigations and CAPA
OOS investigation
The first result failed and the retest passed. The disposition has to explain what happened to the original result.
The inspector asks “Who made the final determination that this OOS result was assignable, and what was the basis?”
Start here
OOS Investigation Case File
Release; the original result was retained, not invalidated.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- An original result of 88.6%, reproduced on re-injection, against retests of 98.8% to 99.2% by a second analyst; none averaged.
- Judgment
- The retests supported release, but the original result was kept; replacing or averaging it was rejected.
- Risk
- The cause of 88.6% was never found; stability assays at 3 and 6 months, with a reopen trigger below 95.0%.
- The Director, Quality Assurance, under named authority, on a stated date and time.
- OOS Investigation Case File Case File $149
- OOS Decision Check Decision tool $49
- Unit 2: What else could explain the result? Practice unit 25 min
- Who Authorized the OOS Investigation Conclusion? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Stability Data Acceptance? Inspection question
- OOS investigation and FDA guidance Guide
- Two qualified reviewers read the same evidence and disagree. What justified the decision to proceed? Article
- A retest passed. Who authorized treating the original OOS result as resolved? Article
- Approved Is Not the Same as Justified Podcast
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual OOS investigation decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Investigations and CAPA
Data integrity
A data anomaly was investigated. The record has to show what supported the conclusion that integrity was not compromised.
The inspector asks “Who made the determination that this data integrity exception did not compromise the reliability of your records?”
Start here
Data Integrity Risk Authorization Case File
Whether the evidence supported concluding that data integrity was not compromised.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- Audit trail review, system records, user activity and investigation evidence, cross-referenced.
- Judgment
- How competing explanations were evaluated, and why the evidence supported the integrity conclusion.
- Risk
- The uncertainty that remains in the conclusion, preserved with it.
- The data-integrity decision authority, with the delegated authority preserved alongside the conclusion.
- Data Integrity Risk Authorization Case File Case File $149
- Decision Reconstruction Kit Decision tool $49
- The Record in Practice, Unit 1: Not every record gap is a writing problem. Practice unit
- Who Authorized the Data Integrity Exception? Inspection question
- Who Authorized This Computerized System Validation? Inspection question
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual data integrity decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Batch release and disposition
Batch release
Every result passed, but conditions were still open when the batch was released. Who weighed them, and on what basis?
The inspector asks “Who authorized this batch release, and what evidence did they review before making that decision?”
Start here
Batch Release Authorization Case File
Whether the batch could be released while conditions were still open.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- Batch records, deviation impact, test results, and excursion review.
- Judgment
- How the available evidence supported the release decision.
- Risk
- Open conditions, residual exposure, and alternatives to release.
- Who authorized release and the basis for that authority.
- Batch Release Authorization Case File Case File Free
- Batch Release Decision Check Decision tool $59
- Unit 2: What do the results show? Practice unit 25 min
- Unit 2: What else could explain the result? Practice unit 25 min
- Who Authorized This Batch Release? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Environmental Monitoring Excursion Decision? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Material Rejection Decision? Inspection question
- Batch release authorization documentation Guide
- When batch release is approved but the decision cannot be reconstructed Executive briefing Free PDF
- Every result passed. What did the results show, and what was concluded from them? Article
- The result is within limit. What else could explain it, and which explanation did the release rest on? Article
- Who authorized the batch release, and why was release justified with this in the history? Article
Coming soon
- The Batch Was Reviewed. Was Release Justified? Webinar Coming soon
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual batch release decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Batch release and disposition
Supplier qualification
A supplier was qualified and material is in use. The record has to show what supported qualification and who approved it.
The inspector asks “Who made the qualification decision for this supplier, and what was the basis for that determination?”
Start here
Supplier Qualification Decision Check
What supported qualifying this supplier, and who authorized it?
No Case File covers this decision yet. Start with the Decision Tool and the inspection question below.
- Supplier Qualification Decision Check Decision tool $39
- Supplier Qualification: Who Authorized This Decision? Inspection question
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual supplier qualification decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Change, validation and documents
Change control
The change looks reasonable. Was it classified correctly, and authorized before anyone implemented it?
The inspector asks “Who made the regulatory impact determination for this change, and what was the basis for that assessment?”
Start here
Change Control Approval Case File
Do not implement; a Prior Approval Supplement is required first.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- The proposed upper limit of 3.5% falls outside the filed range of 1.5% to 2.5%.
- Judgment
- Classified as a major change; classifying it as minor was rejected.
- Risk
- A comparability package is required before implementation or distribution.
- The Vice President, Regulatory Affairs, deciding before planned implementation.
- Change Control Approval Case File Case File $149
- Change Control Decision Check Decision tool $39
- Who Approved This Change Control? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Specification Change? Inspection question
- Who Authorized This Risk Assessment? Inspection question
- Change control risk assessment documentation Guide
- Change control risk assessment Guide
- Validation is complete. Who authorized the change, and why was it ready? Article
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual change control decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Change, validation and documents
Process validation
The PPQ passed on paper, but one batch or trend does not sit right. Is the process actually qualified?
The inspector asks “Who made the determination that this process was validated, and what evidence supported that conclusion?”
Start here
Process Validation Case File
Do not conclude the process is qualified; investigate, extend the PPQ, and define monitoring first.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- Ppk of 1.52, 1.04 and 1.47 across the three PPQ batches. Batch 2 misses the criterion.
- Judgment
- The qualification conclusion was held. “Validated because every result met specification” was rejected.
- Risk
- Investigate the batch 2 hardness trend and run added PPQ batches before any commercial use.
- The Vice President, Quality, deciding before the PPQ report was approved.
- Process Validation Case File Case File $149
- Decision Reconstruction Kit Decision tool $49
- Who Authorized the Process Validation Conclusion? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Validation Protocol Deviation? Inspection question
- Who Authorized the Cleaning Validation Acceptance? Inspection question
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual process validation decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Change, validation and documents
Generated documents
A procedure or batch record was drafted with a generated-text tool. Who checked it against approved sources before use?
The inspector asks “Who cleared this generated document for use, and against what?”
Start here
The AI Never Told Us Case File
Clear the master production record for use, with changes, for one revision only.
Preview the reasoning
- Evidence
- A line-by-line comparison to approved sources, and a requirements checklist written before the review.
- Judgment
- Clearing the draft as generated was rejected; its silence on a requirement was treated as a gap.
- Risk
- Two open items with owners and dates; any revision needs a new review.
- The Head of Quality, under quality unit authority (21 CFR 211.22(c)), not delegated.
- The AI Never Told Us Case File Case File $149
- Decision Reconstruction Kit Decision tool $49
- A tool drafted the document. Who cleared it for use, and against what? Article
- Manufacturing intelligence: who is accountable for the decisions it shapes? Article
- The AI Never Told Us Podcast
Need to preserve the reasoning behind an actual generated documents decision? Explore the Inspection Response Record. $497, or $348 after the $149 Case File credit
Tools for any decision
These apply to whichever decision you are working on.
- Decision Reconstruction KitCould we reconstruct who authorized this, and why, if an inspector asked today? Decision tool $49
- Inspection Question PackWhat will the investigator ask about this decision? Decision tool $29
- The Record in Practice, Unit 4: Could someone who was not there understand the decision?Does the record explain who authorized the decision, on what evidence, and with what open risk? Practice unit Releases December 28
- See a completed Inspection Response RecordHow evidence, judgment, risk and authorization are preserved for one real decision. Free sample
Case Files and Decision Tools are decision-support and reference materials. They do not assess your records, replace your procedures or regulatory judgment, or make GMP decisions. Every Case File is built on a fictional case and names no real company.
