← The Record Behind the Decision
Episode 5 · OOS Investigation · 23 min 42 sec
Approved Is Not the Same as Justified
Samantha and Alex examine two FDA warning letters, Apotex and Tower Laboratories, and the question every Quality team faces: when qualified professionals disagree about the evidence, what record shows why the final decision was justified?
With Samantha and Alex ·
What did this episode raise for you?
Ask about this episode or your situation…
“Our retest passed after the first result failed. What would show the conclusion is justified?”
The assistant is still loading. Use the Find the Right Solution button at the bottom right of this page.
Examine the decision
OOS Investigation Case File
The original result failed. Subsequent testing passed. The investigation lead believes the evidence supports the proposed conclusion. Another experienced Quality professional isn’t convinced. Examine a realistic OOS investigation and the reasoning behind its disposition.
Examine the Case File — $149Sources
Further reading
-
Article · 12 min read
Two qualified reviewers read the same evidence and disagree. What justified the decision to proceed?
Approval shows who authorized a decision, not why the evidence justified it. FDA warning letters show what the missing reasoning looks like, and a review of three past decisions shows whether yours can be explained.
Read the article -
Article · 7 min read
A retest passed. Who authorized treating the original OOS result as resolved?
A passing retest does not erase an OOS result. The record has to show why the conclusion changed.
Read the article -
Next episode · Episode 4
How Do We Know It Worked?
Samantha and Alex examine what a CAPA closure has to prove, and why a signed task list is not proof.
Listen · 21 min 1 sec